It’s Christmas Eve today and time for one of the oldest traditions in the blogosphere: Walter Russell Mead’s Yule Blog. Returning to Providence this year, the Yule Blog begins with an Advent blog on Christmas Eve and continues through the Twelve Days of Christmas to the Feast of the Epiphany. Updated every year, the Yule Blog aims to make the Christmas season merrier by exploring its meaning.


The stockings are hung by the chimney with care at the ancestral Mead mansion; and as I settle down for a long winter’s rest, I am taking a break from politics and war, sort of, to yet another run of our good old-fashioned Yuletide blog.

In particular, I want to blog about Christmas itself and what it means. Somehow my generation decided to leave this part out when we passed down the traditions and the lore we were taught to the next generation: We’ve bought a lot of Christmas presents, but we were too busy to think much about the meaning of the story or to teach the next generation much about this holiday and the religion that it defines. We did a great job teaching about Santa Claus and presents; about nine in ten millennials celebrate Christmas. But, according to this 2017 Pew poll, less than one-third of them think of it as, primarily, a religious festival.

That is where we went wrong. My generation and the generation before us inherited an enormous wealth of spiritual capital from a society shaped by hundreds of years of deep religious faith and engagement. Our environment was shaped by that wealth in ways that many of us did not understand; we took it for granted and, in too many cases, we neither looked deeply into these matters for ourselves nor passed our grounding in the culture and faith of Christianity on down to our heirs.

That was a terrible and costly error and not just because human life separated from the knowledge and love of God is so thin, so poor, so unhappy and so ultimately self-defeating. To throw away the spiritual wealth and social capital that our society’s Christian heritage offers undermines the secular treasures of American life as well. Christianity was and is the foundation of American liberty and democracy. Without the wisdom, tolerance, and self-criticism that a deep engagement with the God of Abraham and the Son in whom He was fully revealed provide, our society will splinter into suspicious parties and factions, our institutions will progressively falter, and neither the government nor society at large will long retain the trust, the honesty, and the spiritual depth without which democracy and many other good things must fail.

Increasingly, Americans are moving away from their Christian roots. According to a recent Pew survey, about one out of eight Americans stopped identifying as Christian in the last decade, and almost one-fourth of the country now reports no religious affiliation. Fifty-four percent of Americans report going to church “very infrequently,” and the drop-off is steeper among young people.

In the last few years, American society has had a little foretaste of what the politics and culture of a post-Christian America might look like. Political life when the virtues of humility, forbearance, honesty, and tolerance begin to fade from our common life is not a pretty thing. Virtue is the secret lubricant that makes all our institutions work smoothly—and it is the secret glue that holds the social structures on which we all rely in place. The farther America moves from its rich heritage of faith, the less well America will work. This isn’t a partisan point. Christianity is the living force behind American liberal ideology as well as behind American conservatism. The values of honesty and tolerance in our national political life are ultimately grounded in the Christian faith that has formed the American conscience for hundreds of years. If we as a people walk away from that faith, the many blessings that it brought us will dry up and blow away. This isn’t a far-off danger; it is already happening. Year by year, our politics become more contentious as the level of honesty and civility in politics decline. We’ve seen how the absence of real faith and spiritual engagement in Hollywood, the media, and political life leads to the objectification of women and the exploitation of the weak. We’ve seen partisanship run amok, hatred take root, and corruption flourish. We’ve seen what happens when national leaders live in flagrant defiance of the moral standards that our country has long upheld. We’ve seen what happens when concepts like duty, honesty, and dignity lose their hold on the public mind and on the behavior of our leaders. We’ve seen what happens when religious leaders, instead of bringing God’s message to the world, begin to project the values, the mindset, and the priorities of the world into their religions missions and communities. Without a change in our spiritual direction, our national life can only decline. The farther Americans stray from the faith that formed us, the harder it becomes for us to maintain the republican and democratic institutions that give us both liberty and peace.

This is not to say by any means that only Christians are real Americans or good Americans. There have been and are today many great Americans who are not Christian, who are atheists, Muslims, agnostics, and Jews. But it is the Christian grounding of the American majority that enabled this country, with all its faults, to become the uniquely tolerant and accepting place that it is. An America that moves away from Christianity will be an America that ultimately moves away from tolerance, pluralism, and respect for individual conscience. As I blog about Christ and Christianity, I hope among other things that this work will help create a more tolerant and accepting culture for those among us who seek God in other faith traditions, or who don’t believe in any kind of God. At least for me, and I think for many other Christians, a personal faith in Christ makes it easier for me to honor and respect each person I encounter, regardless of religious, political, or cultural differences.

The meaning of Christmas is much bigger than the trite clichés that usually come up in this context; I won’t just be writing about the Importance of Giving and the Desirability of Being Nice. Christmas, at least the way I was taught, is a lot more than a merry interlude in the darkest, nastiest time of the year. It is more than getting or even giving. It is more than carols and candy, more than wonderful meals with the people you love best in the world. It is much more than the modern echo of the pagan festivities marking the winter solstice and the moment when the sun begins to reverse its long and slippery slide down the sky.

For Christians—two-thirds of the American people according to Pew—Christmas is the hinge of the world’s fate, the turning point of life. It is the most important thing that ever happened, or at least the beginning of it, and we celebrate it every year because it is still happening now. Whether we know it or not, whether we appreciate it or not, we are part of the Christmas Event that has turned history upside down. There’s a reason why we date the birth of Christ as the year 1 and why traditionally the world’s history was divided into BC, before Christ, and AD, anno domini, the year of the Lord.

Actually, as former Pope Benedict XVI reminded us, the monk who tried to calculate it seems to have gotten it wrong; Jesus was probably born four to six years “BC.” He also did not know about the use of zero as a number; there is no year 0 between AD and BC—which is why irritating pedants remind people at every turn of the century that the “real” new century or millennium doesn’t begin until 2001, for example, rather than on January 1, 2000.

Superficially, Christmas is a simple and user-friendly holiday: presents, tree, more presents, food, mistletoe, deck the halls, and fa-la-la. How hard is that? But if you look beyond the commercial hype and the pop culture celebration, Christmas is a complicated festival that expresses some of the core beliefs that shape the identities and worldviews of about a third of the world’s people. Non-Christians need to know about Christianity as much or perhaps even more as Christians do, simply in order to understand the cultural foundations of the society in which they live.

Religious education has pretty much fallen by the wayside in American life today. That’s a problem in more ways than one; I see the consequences all the time when students I teach—and policymakers and journalists I know—simply do not comprehend the cultural foundations of American politics and cannot understand the ways that so many people here and around the world are moved by religious values and ideas. I have taught a course on the relationship of American religious ideas to American foreign policy in some of our leading colleges, and I have had smart, well-traveled, and otherwise well-read students in that course who have never opened a Bible (or any other holy book) in their lives and simply had no idea why so many other people read and study sacred literature every day of their lives.

For Christians, I hope these blog posts will enrich your experience of this special season. To believe in the truth of the Christian religion and to encounter Jesus Christ as the saving Son of God is just the first step of a faith journey; deepening your faith through reflection and understanding, appreciating faith’s resonances and mysteries, participating in the communion of saints and God’s own life, joining the story and not just reading it: that is what being a Christian is about. A study of Christmas isn’t a bad place to start. The mysteries of the Christian faith are woven into the lessons, the carols, and the prayers of this special time.

I’m trying to blog as a vanilla Christian; that is, I’m trying to write about the elements of our faith that virtually all major Christian communities have historically shared. That puts me at odds with some of the more liberal trends in contemporary American mainline Protestantism; I think the historic statements of Christian doctrine as found in documents like the Nicene Creed make sense and give an accurate and compelling description of what it means to have a Christian faith. I’m an Anglican by conviction as well as by birth, and that will inevitably influence the way I approach Christmas. But I won’t be trying to sneak in special little Anglican concepts here, and this won’t be about controversial ideas that divide Christians like infant baptism, predestination, the infallibility of scripture or, for that matter, the infallibility of the Pope. I hope that Christians of many denominations will find something here that captures what the holiday means to them, and that they will forgive any errors or misapprehensions on my part. These are deep waters, and even stronger swimmers than yours truly have been swept off course in them.

Final disclaimer: I’m not really qualified to do this. Sadly, I’m not someone who has achieved deep spiritual insight through a lifetime of asceticism, deep study, good deeds, and constant prayer. Much of what I’ve learned about the right way to live has come through experiencing the consequences of doing things the wrong way first, and my knowledge of God, such as it is, is more the result of experiencing mercy and forgiveness than some kind of reward for living right. To make matters worse, I’m neither licensed nor trained: As a layman, I have no special theological training and don’t speak with any ecclesiastical authority whatever. If something in this blog troubles you, you should consult with experienced and thoughtful Christians whose lives inspire you, or the leaders of your own church. Christmas is big, and understanding it is hard.

One of the best-known facts about Christmas is that there are 12 days of it; that song about the partridge and the pear tree has echoed through enough American shopping malls and elevators over the years that very few people haven’t gotten the message. But even that is confusing. Traditionally, the 12 days started on December 25; Twelfth Night, the finale of the holiday celebrations, is celebrated on January 6 when the three wise men arrived in Bethlehem. In much of the Spanish speaking world, January 6 is when kids get their Christmas presents. Jesus got gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh; today kids get video games and dolls. January 6 is the thirteenth day after December 25; according to the religious calendar that many Western churches use, it is the Feast of the Epiphany and not part of Christmas at all.

In the old days, people kept a Yule log burning during the holiday season. From now until January 6, I’ll be Yule-blogging: reflecting on Christmas in ways that I hope will make sense to Christians and non-Christians alike. The Yule Blog is a work in progress; each year I try to make it a little clearer, a little more useful, a little less hopelessly inadequate at explaining some of the most important and mysterious truths there are.

Christmas isn’t just the holiday that celebrates the birthday of the Founder of one of the world’s great religions. It’s the main reason so many of the world’s other great religions don’t like Christianity very much. Christians talk about that baby in the manger as God on earth. The monotheistic religions like Judaism and Islam find that idea blasphemous; polytheistic religions like Hinduism wonder why Christians think their own divine birth is so special when so many gods and goddesses have brought so many divine and semi-divine children into the world. Christmas, a holiday that popular culture romanticizes as a time of great peace, is one of the most divisive holidays on the world’s calendar. I want to blog about why.

Meanwhile, Merry Christmas to those of you inclined to celebrate that holiday, and seasonal greetings to everyone else. Whatever your faith or lack of it, however you understand the meaning and purpose of your life, may the next few days be a time of rest, relaxation, and healing reflection for you that brings you closer to those you love, makes you more generous to those in need, and leaves you more in tune with that wiser, happier, richer, and more generous self that it’s your hope, your duty, and, with the help of a merciful God, your destiny to become.